Putters · Facts checked Sep 2026

TaylorMade Spider Tour or Scotty Cameron Phantom 5?

TaylorMade Spider Tour Option A · 2023 · $349.99 at launch Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 Option B · 2026 · $499 at launch

No verdict, on purpose

Length, lie, head weight and toe hang only mean something next to your own stroke. That's a fitting, not a spec sheet. Here are the published facts to take into it.

What actually changes Fact

Balance
23-29 degrees of toe hang with the L-Neck or Small Slant hosel; the counterbalance hosel is face balanced vs Toe hang — Brand says the mid single-bend shaft gives minimum toe flow
Loft
3° vs 3.5° The Phantom 5 is 0.5° weaker.

All specifications Fact

14 specs
SpecTaylorMade Spider TourScotty Cameron Phantom 5
Launch priceLaunch price, not today's price. $349.99 ↗$499 ↗
Head shape Mallet ↗Mallet ↗
BalanceAs the brand describes it. It suggests the stroke the head suits, it doesn't measure your stroke. 23-29 degrees of toe hang with the L-Neck or Small Slant hosel; the counterbalance hosel is face balanced ↗Toe hang — Brand says the mid single-bend shaft gives minimum toe flow ↗
Stock lengths 33", 34", 35" ↗33", 34", 35" ↗
Head weight Not availableNot available
SpecTaylorMade Spider TourScotty Cameron Phantom 5
Model year 20232026
Sold as current YesYes
Loft 3° ↗3.5° ↗
Lie 70° ↗70° ↗
Hosel / neck Small Slant, L-Neck or counterbalance double bend ↗Mid single-bend shaft ↗
Face White TPU Pure Roll insert (Surlyn and aluminium blend, grooves angled at 45 degrees) with HYBRAR ECHO damper ↗Full-face Studio Carbon Steel insert with chain-link milling ↗
Head material Not available303 stainless steel face/body with 6061 aluminum sole/flange ↗
Stock grip SuperStroke Pistol 1.0 (84g) ↗Gray Full Contact ↗
Hands Right-handed and Left-handed ↗Right-handed ↗

Checked Sep 20, 2026 (Spider Tour) and Sep 20, 2026 (Phantom 5) on each brand's own pages. ↗ opens the official source.

What the brands claim Manufacturer claim

5 claims

TaylorMade Spider Tour

  • TaylorMade says the thin-wall undercut and steel wireframe let it push weight outward for high-MOI stability. ↗
  • The True Path alignment panel is claimed to make it easier to see the start line to the hole. ↗
  • The 45-degree grooves in the Pure Roll insert are said to get the ball rolling forward sooner. ↗

Scotty Cameron Phantom 5

  • Brand says the full-face carbon steel insert brings its blade feel into the Phantom mallets. ↗
  • Scotty Cameron says the wing shape and sightlines frame the ball to help start putts on line. ↗

The brands' words, summarised. Not tested by us, and they never change a verdict.

Our take Our assessment (based on published specs)

2 min read

The two most common mallets in professional golf, and their spec sheets disagree about almost everything except lie and length.

The Spider Tour is sold in three hosels — Small Slant, L-Neck and a counterbalance double bend — so its balance isn't one number: TaylorMade publishes 23° to 29° of toe hang for the slant and L-neck, and calls the counterbalance version face balanced. The Phantom 5 comes with a mid single-bend shaft that Scotty Cameron grades as minimum toe flow, which is the closest thing in its range to face balanced without the brand using the phrase.

Faces: TaylorMade's Pure Roll insert with 45° grooves and a damper behind it; Scotty Cameron's full-face milled carbon steel insert. Loft 3.0° against 3.5°. The Phantom 5 is listed right-handed only at this neck; the Spider Tour is offered both ways.

$349.99 against $499 at launch.

Neither page publishes a head weight, which is the spec most likely to change how a mallet feels on fast greens. That's a fitting bay question.

What golfers say Opinion

Be the first

No reviews yet. If you've played the Spider Tour or the Phantom 5, tell other golfers how it went.

Share your take
Which one do you play?

We read every review before it goes up. No links, no prices, nothing personal. Reviews are opinions: they never change a verdict.

Quick answers

4 questions

What's the difference between the TaylorMade Spider Tour and the Scotty Cameron Phantom 5?

On what the brands publish, the TaylorMade Spider Tour is a mallet. On balance: 23-29 degrees of toe hang with the L-Neck or Small Slant hosel; the counterbalance hosel is face balanced. The Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 is a mallet. On balance: Toe hang — Brand says the mid single-bend shaft gives minimum toe flow. The full spec table is on this page, with a source link on every number.

What lengths do they come in?

TaylorMade Spider Tour: 33", 34", 35". Scotty Cameron Phantom 5: 33", 34", 35". Putter length should come from your posture and eye position, not from a default.

What did each one cost new?

The TaylorMade Spider Tour launched at $349.99. The Scotty Cameron Phantom 5 launched at $499.

Which one should I buy?

We don't answer that with specs. A putter fitting — on a real green, with your stroke — decides length, lie, head weight and whether you want toe hang. This page gives you the published facts to take into that fitting.

Other comparisons with these clubs

Compare a different pair vs

Last updated 2026-10-16. Why putters get no verdict: How we rate.