How we rate golf gear

Methodology version 0.7 · Last updated September 20, 2026

GolfCheck answers one question: should you keep what you have, buy used, or buy new? To answer it honestly we separate three kinds of information and label each one on every page.

Three kinds of information

Fact
Specs you can check in an official source: loft options, head volume (cc), lie, length, adjustability, stock shafts, launch price, room size a launch monitor needs, subscription prices. Every fact shows a link to its source and the date we checked it.
Manufacturer claim
What the brand says about its product: "more forgiving", "lower spin", "faster ball speed". We summarize these in our own words and label them. We don't treat them as true or false. They are the brand's words, not ours.
Our assessment
Our editorial read: who the product suits and how it compares. Each assessment says what it is based on: published specs, hands-on testing or third-party test data (with a link). We do not hands-on test every product, and we never present a spec-based read as a test result.

What we never do

Driver verdicts: Keep, Upgrade only if…, or Upgrade

Every driver comparison pits the driver you have (A) against a candidate (B). The verdict comes from the rules below, applied the same way to every pair. A newer release year alone is never a reason to upgrade.

Step 1: look for fit-relevant differences (facts only)

  1. Adjustability. B has an adjustable hosel and A doesn't, or B's loft range is at least 1° wider.
  2. Weighting. B has movable weights or a weight track and A doesn't, so B can be set up to reduce a slice or change launch.
  3. Loft options. B comes in a loft that A doesn't (for example 12°).
  4. Published MOI. Both brands publish a moment-of-inertia figure and B's is at least 10% higher. We only use a number the manufacturer published; we never estimate MOI.
  5. Conformance. A is not on the USGA/R&A Conforming Driver List and B is. This matters only if you play in competitions.

Step 2: the verdict

VerdictWhen
Keep None of the differences above apply, or the only differences are manufacturer claims (speed, feel, "more distance").
Upgrade only if… One or more differences apply. We list each one as a plain condition, for example: "…you fight a slice and would use a draw weight setting, which your current driver doesn't have."
Upgrade A is non-conforming and you play competitions; or two or more differences apply and we have verified current prices showing B used at a retailer for less than the price threshold stated on the page. Until we have verified price data for a pair, the strongest verdict we give is "Upgrade only if…".

A verdict is not a fitting. If you are spending full price on a new driver, a fitting with your own swing will tell you more than any website.

Fairway woods and hybrids: Keep, Upgrade only if…, or Upgrade

The same rule as drivers, applied to the clubs between the driver and the irons. A newer model is not a reason. A club earns a change only when it can do something yours can't:

  1. A loft you can't get. B is sold in a loft your model doesn't offer, more than 1° away from anything in your range (a 9-wood, a 7-hybrid, a stronger 3+).
  2. Adjustability. B has an adjustable hosel and yours doesn't, or its range is at least 1° wider.
  3. Weighting. B has weights you can move and the brand says yours doesn't.
  4. Hand. B is offered left-handed and yours isn't.

Head volume, stock shafts and the brand's speed or launch claims are shown as facts and claims, but they never produce a verdict on their own. As with drivers, "Upgrade" needs verified prices, so until we have them the strongest verdict is "Upgrade only if…".

Iron sets: we compare by loft, not by the number on the club

A 7-iron is not a fixed thing. Brands have been strengthening iron lofts for years, so one brand's 7-iron can have the loft another brand calls an 8-iron. A set whose 7-iron is 2° stronger and half an inch longer will hit the ball farther with that club, and none of that difference comes from the face.

So on every iron comparison we do three things:

  1. We publish the loft of every club in both sets, as the brand publishes it.
  2. We match the clubs by loft. If your 7-iron is 30.5° and the new set's 8-iron is 31°, those are the two clubs that hit the ball a similar distance, and that is the pair we line up.
  3. We say when a distance gain is loft or length. If the new set's 7-iron is at least 1° stronger, or at least 0.25 inch longer, we say so at the top of the page.

The verdict

VerdictWhen
Keep The new set doesn't give you a club, a hand or a shaft you can't already get. Stronger lofts and a longer club are not, by themselves, a reason: your current set can be bent, and a longer club is not a better club.
Upgrade only if… One or more of these applies: the new set covers a loft your set doesn't (a gap the brand fills with a club you don't have); it is offered left-handed and yours isn't; it has a stock graphite shaft and yours is steel only.
Upgrade Reserved for cases with verified prices. Until we have them, the strongest verdict is "Upgrade only if…".

What we never do with irons: turn a brand's forgiveness or distance claim into a verdict, compare two sets' "7-irons" as if they were the same club, or estimate a loft a brand doesn't publish.

Putters: facts, no verdict

We publish putter specs and sources, and we stop there. No Keep, no Upgrade. Two reasons, and we'd rather state them than invent a ranking:

What we do give you: every published number with its source, the brand's own claims kept separate, and the launch price. Take that to a fitting.

Launch monitors: Fits, Fits only if…, or Doesn't fit

For launch monitors we check your situation against the manufacturer's published requirements:

Launch monitor comparisons

We only compare pairs that real buyers weigh against each other, and we only publish a comparison when we have written our own take on it. Each comparison shows the official specs side by side, the five-year cost in a standard scenario (indoors, you already own a phone) and a "Pick X if…" list. There is no overall winner.

Five-year total cost

Our calculator adds hardware, the cheapest published subscription (only if you say you'd pay for one, or if the maker requires it), special balls or stickers and any device you need to buy. If a launch monitor needs a phone or tablet you don't have and it works with Apple devices, we add the cheapest current iPad. If it needs something else (for example a Windows PC), we say so and leave that cost out rather than guess it. Every assumption is shown next to the result with its source. When no official source exists (for example, how many balls you'll use per year), the number is labeled GolfCheck estimate, we explain it, and you can change it.

Where our data comes from

Corrections

If a spec is wrong, tell us which page and link the official source. We fix it and update the verification date.

Changes to this methodology